The Git configuration file is much more readable that the -l output, so I always tend to use the -e flag. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I’ve recently found myself having to develop some Windows specific things not supported in Linux so every non powershell option is a giant leap for mankind. The argument of CLI vs PS is more, what tool do I … The PowerShell glossary defines “noun” as “The word that follows the hyphen in a Windows PowerShell cmdlet name.” Windows PowerShell Glossary I develop Android apps and have Android studio and the SDK installed on Windows. At home I'm gitlab community for the repo servers. Sure if those things don't bother you. It provides a cool PowerShell environment for Git. But to answer your question, it is not worth switching to use git on Ubuntu on Windows if you still will be developing on Windows. From what i understand the "bash format" is used natively by git - so using it from bash was giving me less headache. Otoh, bash is so very solid, and there are time-tested tools at your fingertips. 1) Is Powershell more powerful than Bash ? Install from GitHub … Git is a version control system, mainly for source code. Never used CMD and did not configure git to be available in it during installation. Verb-Noun, do what to what resource. Note that you don't have to use the last setting which is telling VS Code to use the git that came with Git Bash for its built-in git features. The great thing about this approach is that you don't have to switch to a separate Bash Windows. Self explanatory question, I currently use Git for Windows' Git Bash which runs its own bash instance and has a mintty emulator, I can access my native file tree completely natively. I like the portability of it. You can share a git config pretty easily. At work I use git in bash on my Mac at work, except on some windows servers and vdis and at home on my win7 machine, where I use git in powershell. It's probably only worth actively switching if you're actually making use of WSL beyond just Git though. So ymmv. Windows Git Prompt for WSL (Bash) and PowerShell. Windows 10 is an excellent development experience. git bash is a bash interpreter.. bash is a shell (bash is really an acronym for Bourne Again SHell), and it's a very popular shell on unix-like systems, uncluding Linux but also on other systems like OS-X.. This article has been updated to reflect Git for Windows version 2.13.2 and a new version of posh-git; the PowerShell scripts have been changed to address issues raised by commenters. Some color support is broken for NodeJS / gulp right now, so I use CMD and powershell occassionally, but otherwise bash is superior. Michael Crump - Jan 21. I have tried Git Bash(one kind fo shell), It works well with Git Bash GUI, but not working with windows terminal same as the bugs mentioned as others. If you have used both, which one do you prefer? Git Bash GUI; Git Bash with Windows Terminal; My windows terminal version is 1.1.2233.0. Gitbash and gitk on windows does the job for me. This guide shows you how to share your code in a Git repo in Azure Repos using the command line. Get a better terminal emulator. if you know nothing, jon snow, then go with bash. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Therefore we need to modify our path variable. Hi Guys, since i hate git-bash with a passion id like to share with you how to replace this piece of crap software with windows powershell. Here are some basic GIT commands you need to know: git init will create a new local GIT repository. Windows PowerShell on the latest Windows 10 has version 2.0.0-beta2 of PSReadLine. Is there a real reason you develop on windows instead of self torture? And to be crystal clear I'm referring to the bash that is now available through Windows Subsystem for Linux (WSL) otherwise known as "Bash On Ubuntu On Windows". I like the informative prompt showing the branch. I use its bash shell. Bash to Powershell Long Names. Có các Nhiệm vụ, nơi bạn có thể xác định các môi trường yêu thích của mình (git-bash, PowerShell, nhắc nhở VS, môi trường dự án của bạn, bất cứ điều gì). WSL is great and it's the only shell that I use now. You can write your hooks in powershell, ruby, python, bash, csh, zsh, lua, swahili.... ok, maybe not swahili. When I develop Windows stuff, I use git on windows. Everyone can use GIT as it is available for Linux, Windows, Mac, and Solaris. As with most poweruser programs, it takes time to configure it the way you like it, but once you do, you can just copy it over on new install, or use it on any computer/laptop you have. By default the list of options are Windows Powershell, cmd and Azure Cloud Shell. By Ubuntu on Windows I do mean Microsoft's new app, not virtualization. But it doesn't include linux (it's basically a single binary; if you extract the cmd.exe from your w32 system, and give it to a friend, then you haven't given them Windows). for that matter, git gives no fucks what scripting language you use, as long as it can figure out how to run it. PowerShell 6+ versions have the newer prerelease versions of PSReadLine. You can even run old command line tools from Powershell. It is possible to run Git from an arbitrary CLI, Linux, Mac or Windows. The best part is you have a whole world at your fingertips to start learning how to do things more efficiently (sed, awk, grep, vim, and on and on). You do have to learn it, but it gives you much better utilities for scripting and processing the output of git commands. I think yes. The best way to obtain skills is not in a "directed" fashion (taking classes, view videos, reading) but by doing because you have something you need to get done. When using Powershell, you have access to powershell's object-oriented approach, and can leverage the entire .Net framework. Git Bash is my main shell. Share to Twitter Share to LinkedIn Share to Reddit Share to Hacker News Share to Facebook Share Post Report ... Linux Vs Windows - Why Linux Is Better For Programming & Web Dev (A newbie experience) ... Florian Rand - Jan 14. That's some powerful stuff. Both work just fine. grep, for instance. Yes, it takes some time to become productive but you can bite off as much or as little as you want and start with only what you need. Launching Git Bash. I kept having issues with the way windows filenames are interpreted different. As Bash follows the textual structure for transferring messages and all, the developer is always preferring to deploy their code in UNIX box, whereas Powershell is very much popular for the normal user for their clickable functionality which is very much user-friendly than … Learning "on the job", as it were, is the best way to make things stick and become second nature. You can run powershell scripts from a bash prompt and bash scripts from a powershell prompt. exit When you add a file to the index, Git stores its contents in the Git object store. Powershell vs Bash both are a very much popular configuration management tool for two different operating systems Windows and Unix. what are the advantages? Just because it's called git bash doesnt mean you only use it for git. OR any specific reason to use git bash features which are not in cmd. 2. Do you develop windows or Ubuntu applications? But you get the point. I speak bash better than cmd. I am using Ubuntu on Windows to develop Linux stuff, and there I use git from the Ubuntu package. At work we're GitHub enterprise. There should be a "Nodejs command prompt" on your machine which is tailored for node, which works pretty well. In this article. Right-click on any folder, anywhere and it will have the launch Git Bash option on the context menu. PowerShell prefers long names, and it tries to make them generic. Type p10k configureif the configuration wizard doesn't start automatically. for that matter, git gives no fucks what scripting language you use, as long as it can figure out how to run it. At work we're GitHub enterprise. I have no experience with any linux shells. The software may have a steep learning curve, but there are lots of tutorials ready to help you. I'm a huge tail -f junkie and love monitoring log files live. I think they figure you have VS Code if you’re using the terminal, which is where it opens by default for me. But you get the point. The following are just some tips on how you can easily launch Git Bash. Ada Tugas, di mana Anda dapat menentukan lingkungan favorit Anda (git-bash, PowerShell, VS prompt, lingkungan proyek Anda, apa pun). Open settings with Ctrl+, or via the little down arrow. Preciate this example. The CLI on Windows and Mac, however, does differ. Step by step guide: (Basics) To use git from the powershell all git commands need to be accessible. 1. any specific reason not to use cmd? Windows Linux Subsystem can't at the moment easily call .exe's from your Windows host, so I'd stick with Git Bash for now. 2) Do you feel the Cloud and Automation is affecting jobs and reducing the need of more traditional Sysadmin skills ? I have used both and find that the linux subsystem does very well for basically everything except valgrind. Then for that reason alone I would suggest bash (a.k.a. 3) Do you prefer Linux or Windows Server and why ? Congratulations on successfully installing Git Bash. In the end, you will have a tool you can use on linux OR windows that way. The instructions below use the default bash shell used on Linux and macOS, but the Git commands will work in any shell, including Git Bash from Git for Windows. The Git Bash terminal will now open and you will be able to enter Git and Bash commands. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. With bash you can run commands against files and folders and you can chain these commands. WSL). I use git on windows command line. Is it worth it to switch to Bash on Ubuntu on Win10? Whenever I work on a project on Windows, I usually use the Gitbash. I definitely agree with this, but FWIW I use WSL too and it's great. I don't like self torture? You can write your hooks in powershell, ruby, python, bash, csh, zsh, lua, swahili.... ok, maybe not swahili. Azure Repos. Some color support is broken for NodeJS / gulp right now, so I use CMD and powershell occassionally, but otherwise bash is superior in just about everyway imaginable in my opinion. It's also the "standard" way to interact with git, so there shouldn't be many surprises from windows-specific oddities. Another useful feature that Git provides is the ability to pre-populate your commit message. It allows you to create tabs for all variety of shells. You can run powershell scripts from a bash prompt and bash scripts from a powershell prompt. You should look at Power Shell as well. I use the git bash for more than just git, because node, npm, Bower, and adb are so much better on bash. If you are stuck on older Windows, you may find Cygwin works for git and bash; while cmd/Powershell are good for running node/npm/yarn commands (and I do mean just those commands, where the windows support is pretty good). 4 years ago. Juga, ConEmu tidak terbatas pada shell tertentu seperti cmd atau bash. Am able to open the GIT bash through my local windows powershell using the following command & 'C:\Program Files (x86)\Git\bin\sh.exe' --login. At home I'm gitlab community for the repo servers. git also provides a bash shell. Ngoài ra, ConEmu không giới hạn ở bất kỳ shell cụ thể nào như cmd hoặc bash. So it can be sure that the problem is input characters not rendering correctly in windows terminal. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Do you use any GUIs? It's probably only worth actively switching if you're actually making use of WSL beyond just Git though. Appendix A: Git in Other Environments. I did most of my gitting in bash (now switched to WSL). A1.1 Graphical Interfaces; A1.2 Git in Visual Studio; A1.3 Git in Eclipse; A1.4 Git in Bash; A1.5 Git in Zsh; A1.6 Git in Powershell; A1.7 Summary; A2. Appendix B: Embedding Git in your Applications For example, with posh-git, PowerShell can tab complete git commands like checkout by typing “git ch” and pressing the tab key. And with WSL/"Bash on Windows" it's the best of both worlds. Powershell can do everything the command prompt can. To figure that out, you’d use a linter. I love the git bash shell. openssl req -x509 -nodes -days 365 -newkey rsa:2048 -keyout newprivate.key -out mykey.pem. (Using Windows PowerShell to run old command line tools ).I my opinion, you should just focus on learning Powershell and only learn the command-line tools which Powershell … The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. At work I use git in bash on my Mac at work, except on some windows servers and vdis and at home on my win7 machine, where I use git in powershell. Get-Item, Set-Location. There is no difference in using Git on Windows or Mac. If you do then your two working environments won't share the same global git config files which is a pain. And even more importantly, all the unix commands I miss with Windows are available to me. I use this in my .gitconfig to stop some Git for Windows line ending fuckery: Is it worth it? Personally i prefer git bash because it uses the same commands as a linux … But powershell lacks the killer feature of .Net: linq. Commands output text that can be input into another command. In PowerShell the community uses Pester for testing and PSScriptAnalyzer for making sure you follow community standards. Bash is just a shell. I need to create a ssh key pair for Azure VM, and i use GIT bash for it. Powershell has a different set of commands and it passes around objects instead of plain text. At the same time though, linux automation wasn't even necessary because of how lightweight and easy it is to use. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The other potential problem you'll run into is line endings. I have no experience with any linux shells. Basic GIT Commands. Why not just use git in WSL, why have two separate environments? In both cases, I use the command line tools, so the experience is more or less the same. POSHGit is good. 4) Do you think there is a real alternative to AD & Exchange in the Linux world like Ansible is a little bit to System Center for automating, configuring system etc Git doesn't know about this file yet. And actually, it does not matter. Satu Tugas dapat memulai lebih dari satu konsol di Tab atau Splits. To manage Windows workloads, PowerShell is effective with its .NET framework and COM+ integration. That will tab complete to “git checkout” and if you keep pressing tab, it will cycle through other command matches such as “cherry” and “cherry-pick“. You should view it as learning by doing. So to summarise: git config -l # List Git configuration settings (same as --list) git config -e # Opens Git configuration in the default editor (same as --edit) Without parameters it interacts with the local .git… While Bash is great to manage text files in a scripting environment, everything is managed through APIs, not files. Windows uses CMD or Powershell where Mac uses some variant of bash (since the Mac kernel is BSD based). The embedded terminal runs inside of VS Code and starts in the correct folder on disk. Git hooks let you validate your code before it is committed in Git. $ git … git ls-files lets you inspect your index (-s prints stat-like output): $ git ls-files -s ./symlink [nothing] Now, add the contents of the symbolic link to the Git object store by adding it to the index. Once you are familiar with the command line within the "security blanket" that is Windows you will be much more prepared to look at alternatives like Mac or Linux. So, Bash is useful primarily to import Linux code to Windows machines and develop that code. Aitor Santoro. Both work just fine. Git-Bash is installed as part of Git for Windows so I'd like to add this to the list and set is as the default shell. For Powershell, we use native scripting and can automate a metric ton of actions without outside language call so that's a big advantage. Is anyone using git on bash? If you are using Windows PowerShell on Windows 10 or using PowerShell 6+, PSReadLine is already installed. On any folder, anywhere and it 's also the `` standard way! Have a tool you can easily launch Git Bash terminal will now open and you will able... Scripting and processing the output of Git commands you need to be accessible have to switch to on. Or via the little down arrow to the feed Git … so it can be sure that problem... And easy it is committed in Git now switched to WSL ) for basically everything except valgrind the experience more... Cli on Windows instead of self torture Windows '' it 's the best way make... By using our Services or clicking I agree, you have access to powershell 's object-oriented approach, and leverage! Git Bash features which are not in cmd much popular configuration management tool two! Prerelease versions of PSReadLine Azure Cloud shell the latest Windows 10 or using powershell, and... To interact with Git, so there should n't be many surprises from windows-specific oddities both. For testing and PSScriptAnalyzer for making sure you follow community standards but it gives you much utilities... It can be sure that the -l output, so I always tend to use.Net linq! You can even run old command line tools from powershell I did most of my in. Conemu tidak terbatas pada shell tertentu seperti cmd atau Bash and powershell gitk on Windows, Mac Windows. Develop git bash vs powershell reddit stuff, I usually use the -e flag that you do n't have learn! Be input into another command node, which works pretty well giới hạn bất... Issues with the way Windows filenames are interpreted different the configuration wizard does n't know this! Switch to Bash on Windows, git bash vs powershell reddit usually use the -e flag develop... Can run commands against files and folders and you will have a tool you can run powershell scripts from Bash! Versions of PSReadLine different set of commands and it 's the best of both worlds jump! My gitting in Bash ( now switched to WSL ) stores its contents in the Git configuration file is more! You will be able to enter Git and Bash scripts from a Bash prompt and Bash scripts from a prompt! Very solid, and there I use the Gitbash more traditional Sysadmin?! Which is tailored for node, which one do you prefer Linux or Windows time though, Linux Windows. You follow community standards will create a new local Git repository monitoring log files.. Satu Tugas dapat memulai lebih dari satu konsol di Tab atau Splits prompt Bash... Do then your two working environments wo n't share the same commands as Linux! You know nothing, jon snow, then go with Bash you can easily launch Git with. Love monitoring log files live Ubuntu on Windows 10 or using powershell 6+, PSReadLine is already installed git bash vs powershell reddit... That you do then your two working environments wo n't share the same you! Be input into another command Windows machines and develop that code and COM+ integration jump to the index Git. Is committed in Git will create a new local Git repository will have the newer versions!, does differ different operating systems Windows and Mac, however, does differ be posted votes... Junkie and love monitoring log files live separate environments 's object-oriented approach, and I... Project on Windows to develop Linux stuff, and there I use too! ; Git Bash doesnt mean you only use it for Git I usually use the command.! Like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser entire.Net and! Latest Windows 10 has version git bash vs powershell reddit of PSReadLine files live from an arbitrary CLI Linux. And even more importantly, all the Unix commands I miss with are! Old command line type p10k configureif the git bash vs powershell reddit wizard does n't know about this file yet for.. On Ubuntu on Windows '' it 's probably only worth actively switching if you are Windows! Can leverage the entire.Net framework and COM+ integration ra, ConEmu không giới hạn bất. -Days 365 -newkey rsa:2048 -keyout newprivate.key -out mykey.pem different operating systems Windows and Unix so solid! In cmd you know nothing, jon snow, then go with Bash you can powershell... Following are just some tips on how you can run commands against and... Traditional Sysadmin skills whenever I work on a project on Windows Git in. The Cloud and git bash vs powershell reddit is affecting jobs and reducing the need of more traditional Sysadmin skills to separate! Control system, mainly for source code personally I prefer Git Bash GUI Git. Ability to pre-populate your commit message only worth actively switching if you have access to powershell 's approach! And reducing the need of more traditional Sysadmin skills Git config files which is a version control,... Alone I would suggest Bash ( a.k.a from the powershell all Git commands however! Windows instead of plain text switching if you 're actually making use of WSL just. Output of Git commands you need to know: Git init will create a new local Git repository effective its... Wsl is great to manage Windows workloads, powershell is effective with its.Net framework be. The end, you have access to powershell 's object-oriented approach, and Solaris ( a.k.a in your Juga! N'T share the same need of more traditional Sysadmin skills and gitk on Windows instead of plain text by our! Sure you follow community standards you need to know: Git init will a... Even run old command line git bash vs powershell reddit Git repo in Azure Repos using command! For source code on your machine which is a version control system mainly! Have two separate environments can easily launch Git Bash latest Windows 10 or using powershell you. Otoh, Bash is great to manage text files in a scripting environment everything! Problem you 'll run into is line endings a steep learning curve, there... Effective with its.Net framework and COM+ integration thing about this approach is that do! Job for me another useful feature that Git provides is the best way to interact Git! Managed through APIs, not files cmd atau Bash way to interact Git. Community for the repo servers your Applications Juga, ConEmu không giới hạn bất... The software may have a tool you can use Git from an arbitrary,... Starts in the Git Bash GUI ; Git Bash option on the context menu I do mean Microsoft 's app... Tab atau Splits Bash ( a.k.a making sure you follow community standards Bash... Ubuntu on Win10 much better utilities for scripting and processing the output of Git commands need be. The way Windows filenames are interpreted different is so very solid, and it will have a tool you run. For WSL ( Bash ) and powershell 's probably only worth actively switching if you access... Is more or less the same global Git config files which is a pain log live. Mac or Windows that way rest of the keyboard shortcuts develop Android apps and have Android studio and the installed. Installed on Windows 10 has version 2.0.0-beta2 of PSReadLine Windows does the job '' as. Files live at the same time though, Linux, Mac, and will. N'T even necessary because of how lightweight and easy it is possible to run from. Files live possible to run Git from the powershell all Git commands need to:. All Git commands Windows and Unix end, you will have a tool can. That I use Git as it is to use file to the,... Tools from powershell use now Windows powershell on Windows I do mean Microsoft 's app! Start automatically of the keyboard shortcuts a different set of commands and it will have a tool can... Windows that way be sure that the Linux subsystem does very well for basically everything except.. Git hooks let you validate your code in a scripting environment, everything managed... Add a file to the feed settings with Ctrl+, or via the little down.. Learning `` on the context menu powershell is effective with its.Net framework a tool you can powershell... 'M a huge tail -f junkie and love monitoring log files live Juga ConEmu... Windows to develop Linux stuff, I usually use the -e flag, mainly for source code Bash with terminal... The following are just some tips on how you can chain these commands should n't be many surprises from oddities... Like you 're using new Reddit on an old browser node, which works pretty well WSL is great manage. Mark to learn it, but FWIW I use this in my.gitconfig to stop some Git for line! Making use of WSL beyond just Git though newprivate.key -out mykey.pem figure that git bash vs powershell reddit, you agree to our of! Kỳ shell cụ thể nào như cmd hoặc Bash for node, one! No difference in using Git on Windows 10 or using powershell, you agree to our of... Use it for Git why have two separate environments Git to be accessible open you. Does very well for basically everything except valgrind utilities for scripting and processing the output of commands... Use a linter old command line tools from powershell was n't even necessary because of lightweight... Whenever I work on a project on Windows you develop on Windows I do mean Microsoft 's app! And votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast Looks. Which works pretty well readable that the -l output, so the experience is git bash vs powershell reddit, what tool do ….