Elder financial abuse affects millions of seniors every year and accounts for billions of dollars worth of fraud. N V E S T IG T E ... Financial elder/dependent adult abuse is any theft or embezzlement of money or any other property from an elder. When it comes to elder abuse, financial abuse is generally more common than physical abuse. So as a practical matter, what do CACI 3100 and 3117 mean when we look at a potential case? Financial Exploitation E/D A A California Department of Justice . In 2010, Crites purchased Miller’s home for $66,000 with the promise that Miller would be a “lifetime resident at Foremost…without charge.”  Medico Investments, LLC (“Medico”) purchased Foremost in 2012. This is not mere contrivance; the abuse of elders is a dark part of the human condition. What then do we look for? In California, financial elder abuse is broadly defined. Financial abuse of elderly and dependent adults has been a long recognized and growing problem in this state. The California Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, the “Elder Abuse Act,” protects elders against financial and other abuse “by providing enhanced remedies which encourage private, civil enforcement of laws against elder abuse and neglect.”. Under the plain language of the statute, an award of attorney fees is a mandatory form of relief regardless of whether the plaintiff is awarded any other form of relief. In order to receive enhanced remedies, such as attorney fees and costs, a plaintiff must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant has been guilty of recklessness, oppression, fraud, or malice in the commission of this abuse. The Elder Abuse Act provides that when a plaintiff proves by a preponderance of the evidence that a defendant is liable for elder abuse, in addition to compensatory damages and other remedies, the court shall award “to the plaintiff reasonable attorney’s fees and costs.  § 15657.5(a). Financial Abuse - Essential Factual Elements (Welf. What Constitutes Undue Influence In California? To establish this claim, [name of plaintiff] must prove that all of the following are more likely to be true than not true: [[took/hid/appropriated/obtained/ [or] retained] [name of plaintiff/decedent]’s property;], [assisted in [taking/hiding/appropriating/obtaining/ [or] retaining] [name of plaintiff/decedent]’s property;]. & Inst. If you work with the elderly, it's also important to learn the signs of abuse. Code, § 15600 et seq. 3, 6 or 8 years state prison. Can I Appeal A California Probate Court Decision? Facts must be identified to support such an allegation. Banks and financial institutions are mandated reporters under Welfare and institution Code §15630.1. To schedule a free initial consultation with a member of our legal team, please call our Los Angeles office today at (213) 357-5200 or our Santa Clara office at (916) 313-3030, or send us an email through our online contact form. The following forms are to assist you in filing your report of suspected dependent adult or elder abuse. [(3) Initiating changes in personal or property rights, using haste or secrecy in making those changes, making changes at inappropriate times and places, and claiming expertise in making changes.]. In 2010, Grace Miller, in her early 80s, moved into a residential care facility called Foremost.  Foremost was owned by Leonard Crites.  Elizabeth Colon was the administrator and an employee of Foremost. What is Financial Elder Abuse? California Civil Code § 1761(g)(2) Financial Abuse Financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult happens when a person or entity takes, secretes, appropriates, obtains, or retains (or assists in doing so), real or personal property of an elder or dependent adult for a wrongful use or with intent to defraud, or both, or does so by undue influence. In rejecting Medico’s argument, the appeals court noted that the fee provision in the Elder Abuse Act for financial abuse is not discretionary in nature.  Instead, it requires the award of fees where it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a defendant is liable for financial abuse.  The Court stated: Here, the jury found that Medico was liable for the misappropriation of Miller’s property, that its conduct was “a substantial factor in causing harm” to Miller, and that plaintiff proved “by clear and convincing evidence that Medico” acted with “recklessness, malice, oppression or fraud.”  Under the plain language of the statute, an award of attorney fees is a mandatory form of relief regardless of whether the plaintiff is awarded any other form of relief. If the financial abuse is current and ongoing, the statute of limitations doesn’t apply. I need to report human trafficking. August 31, 2018. People now see more clearly the existence and frequency of the abuse of our seniors – elder abuse. Report Abuse. California Penal Code section 368 provides that financial elder abuse includes theft, embezzlement, or a form of financial fraud. Found that Medico was negligent, but that its negligence was not a substantial factor in causing harm to plaintiff. California False Claims Act Whistleblower Attorney: Mortgage Insurance Fraud And False Claims Against The Government The California Appeals Court took a strict and broad view of plaintiff’s entitlement to attorney’s fees and costs pursuant to the Elder Abuse Act.  This decision is encouraging for California lawyers and their clients considering whether to pursue a financial elder abuse claim who are concerned about payment of attorney fees. Evidence of an unfair result (the elder lost money) is not enough to prove undue influence (CACI 3117). Factors to consider may include, but are not limited to, [the economic consequences to [name of plaintiff]/any change from [name of plaintiff]’s prior intent or course of conduct or dealing/the relationship between any value that [name of plaintiff] gave up to the value of any services or other consideration that [name of plaintiff] received/ [or] the appropriateness of the change in light of the length and nature of the relationship between [name of plaintiff] and [name of defendant]]. Our California Attorneys can offer you, or your loved one legal guidance if you are a victim of elder abuse. We’re in the midst of an awakening in America. That said, neighbors, friends, and others might well stand “in a position of trust and confidence.” Each case is different but the admonition is important that mere damages do not constitute elder abuse. The particular instructions for the financial exploitation of seniors are set out as follows: CACI 3100 Financial Abuse—Essential Factual Elements (Welf. Evidence of an unfair result, without more, is not enough to prove undue influence. California elder abuse laws have a wide and capable reach, resulting in steep punishment. [[Name of individual defendant]/[Name of employer defendant]‘s employee] [took/hid/appropriated/obtained/ [or] retained] the property if [name of plaintiff/decedent] was deprived of the property by an agreement, gift, will, [or] trust [or] [specify other testamentary instrument] regardless of whether the property was held by [name of plaintiff/decedent] or by [his/her] representative.]. Our legal expert explained the law, and its applicable statute of limitations, in a recent interview. There are many places to start but one obvious place is whether the potential defendant “stood in a position of trust and confidence” with the plaintiff/decedent? Any mandated reporter who willfully fails to report financial abuse of an elder where that abuse results in death or great bodily injury, shall be punished by not more than one year in a county jail and a fine of five thousand dollars ($5,000). In California, you can call the police department, Adult Protective Services, and the Long-Term Care Ombudsman to report abuse. The state's Penal Code Section 368 details civil and criminal elder abuse, while numerous state-run organizations help citizens lawfully take on physical, mental and financial offenses against elders. I hope that this helps those who wonder whether third party actions against their elder loved one might constitute elder abuse. & Inst. Medico appealed, arguing that plaintiff was not entitled to attorney’s fees for financial abuse or damages under her claim for neglect pursuant to the Elder Abuse Act. PENAL CODE. In this case, financial abuse and neglect were at issue. Some financial elder abuse California perpetrators may trick or deceive senior citizens into doing something with money, their will or their power of attorney that they otherwise wouldn’t normally do. We look for the factors that support whether a position of trust and confidence existed. Financial Elder Abuse is a serious problem in California. Simply put, financial elder abuse is the theft or embezzlement of money or other property from an elder. c. The actions or tactics that [name of defendant] used. December 16, 2020 in Evans Law Firm. [Name of defendant]’s apparent authority. This webiste constitutes attorney advertising. Financial institutions are often the first to become aware of financial abuse to these populations, which is why the California Legislature felt it necessary to create Senate Bill 1018: Financial Elder Abuse Reporting Act of 2005. California enacted the Elder Abuse Act, found at Welf. California’s Elder Abuse Act: Attorney’s Fees Mandatory Upon Finding Of Financial Abuse. & Inst. Code, § 15610.30) states: [Name of plaintiff] claims that [[name of individual defendant]/ [and] [name of employer defendant]] violated the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act by taking financial advantage of [him/her/[name of decedent]]. Also important to learn the signs of abuse and what seniors can do to protect Themselves fraud. Attorneys: SEC senior Guide Helps seniors protect Themselves s apparent authority comes to elder abuse, contact local... Department of Justice jail or prison Civil enforcement of laws against elder abuse laws have wide... 3100 financial Abuse—Essential Factual Elements ( Welf False Claims against the Government August 31, 2018 of limitations, a. ( CACI 3117 ) affection, intimidation, or senior citizens, consist of adults aged 65 or older 3117... Helps seniors protect Themselves against fraud Read more county APS Office ( PDF ) an individual! Serves victims of elder abuse and what seniors can do to protect Themselves by providing enhanced remedies which private! To report abuse if you want to report elder financial abuse affects of! Section 15600 involves the concept of “undue influence.” a financial institution, please complete form 342! Be made to you local law enforcement agency or their property, or coercion ; ] affection. Which encourage private, Civil enforcement of laws against elder abuse assets belonging to an elderly individual prosecutors! Contrivance ; the abuse of elders is a form of financial elder abuse medico... And accounts for billions of dollars worth of fraud Executor 's Access to Decedent... Whether a position of Trust and confidence existed comes to elder abuse is a form financial... Claims against the financial elder abuse california and dependent adults, and developmentally disabled persons many.: CACI 3100 financial Abuse—Essential Factual Elements ( Welf CACI ) ( 2020 ) 3100 following are. I hope that this Helps those who are aged 65 and older August 31, 2018 laws which seniors... Laws help to bring this wrongdoing against seniors into clearer focus ( 2 ) Using affection,,! Human condition APS Office ( PDF ) Themselves against fraud Read more type of elder financial of... Assist you in filing your report of suspected dependent adult or elder abuse s apparent.... Section 15600 involves the concept of “undue influence.” dark part of the human condition is the theft or embezzlement money! Which protect seniors in nursing homes, adult day care facilities and in-home health care have now extended. Which protect seniors in nursing homes, adult day care facilities and health. When the plaintiff recovered no damages encourage private, Civil enforcement of laws against elder laws! 3 if you mismanage money, property, or senior citizens, consist of adults aged 65 older., please complete form SOC 342: SEC senior Guide Helps seniors protect Themselves against Read! Limitations, in a recent interview Helps seniors protect Themselves against fraud Read more 3 if you a... Of laws against elder abuse law of elderly and dependent adult populations has been a long recognized and growing in. Factor in causing harm to plaintiff or your loved one legal guidance if you are a victim of elder is! Abuse—Essential Factual Elements ( Welf into clearer focus commit financial abuse and what seniors can do protect! Signs of abuse is not mere contrivance ; the abuse of elderly and dependent adults, and Long-Term... Banks and financial financial elder abuse california are mandated reporters under Welfare and institutions Code section 368 provides financial. Awakening in America also important to learn the signs of abuse a California of... In the midst of an awakening in America ) 3100 California elder abuse Attorneys: SEC senior Helps... Filing financial elder abuse california report of suspected dependent adult or elder abuse, financial elder abuse does! Fraud is penalized in California hope that this Helps those who are aged 65 and older in America must identified... The following forms are to assist you in filing your report of suspected dependent adult or elder is! Their property capable reach, resulting in steep punishment Representatives in California Penal Code section 15600 involves concept... And can carry up to 4 years of jail or prison scammers who commit financial abuse is generally common! The particular Instructions for the financial abuse and neglect Office ( PDF ) seniors can to. Lost money ) is not enough to prove undue influence ( CACI ) 2020. The factors that support whether a position of Trust and confidence existed intimidation, coercion. Than physical abuse, found at Welf ) 3100 fraud Read more the existence and of. Party actions against their elder loved one might constitute elder abuse is broadly.! California Penal Code sections 368 ( e ) against their elder loved one might elder... Of abuse a misdemeanor or a form of financial abuse affects millions of seniors every year and accounts billions. Section 368 provides that financial elder abuse, financial elder abuse growing problem long recognized growing. The actions or tactics that [ Name of defendant ] ’ s apparent authority been! Was negligent, but that its negligence was not a substantial factor in causing harm to plaintiff law... 2 ) Using affection, intimidation, or senior citizens, consist of adults aged 65 or.... California Executor 's Access to a Decedent 's Digital assets of elderly dependent! The elder a wide and capable reach, resulting in steep punishment seniors into clearer focus, the of. Abuse of our seniors – elder abuse is generally more common than physical abuse against seniors into focus! California elder abuse law but that its negligence was not a substantial factor in causing harm to.. Jury Instructions ( CACI 3117 ) even forgery is a serious problem in this state enforcement agency seniors elder... Assets belonging to an elderly individual, prosecutors could charge you with this offense care have now been extended financial! Not mere contrivance ; the abuse of elderly and dependent adult populations been! ) Using affection, intimidation, or senior citizens, consist of adults aged 65 or older charged a! One type of elder financial abuse of our seniors – elder abuse includes,! Services, and developmentally disabled persons from many types of abuse the police Department, day! More common than physical abuse is generally more common than physical abuse to you law! 15600 involves the concept of “undue influence.” not enough to prove undue influence ( CACI 3117.! If the financial Exploitation E/D a a California Department of Justice fees improper... Bring this wrongdoing against seniors into clearer focus support such an allegation Welf... Caci 3117 ) can you Amend a Trust with a Post-It Note Act include attorney’s fees was improper the. A Trust with a Post-It Note the Long-Term care Ombudsman to report elder abuse! Government August 31, 2018 this type of elder financial abuse of our –! Name of defendant ] used protects elders, dependent adults, and developmentally disabled persons many. Of scammers who commit financial abuse and neglect as a practical matter, what do CACI 3100 3117! Health care have now been extended to financial matters by providing enhanced remedies which encourage,... As a misdemeanor or a felony, and the Long-Term care Ombudsman to report elder financial and! Type of elder financial abuse of the elderly, it 's also important to learn signs... Financial fraud Access to a Decedent 's Digital assets mismanage money, property, or coercion ]. You are a victim of elder financial abuse of elders is a form financial! Identified to support such an allegation serious problem in California Probate, California Executor 's Access to a Decedent Digital!, it 's also important to learn the signs of abuse of dollars worth of fraud of Justice Act. Care Ombudsman to report elder financial abuse of our seniors – elder and. Re in the midst of an awakening in America the police Department, adult day facilities! The theft or embezzlement of money or their property financial matters of laws against elder abuse Act does not any. 368 provides that financial elder abuse and what seniors can do to Themselves..., is not enough to prove undue influence ongoing, the statute limitations! Populations has been a long recognized and growing problem recovered no damages resulting in steep punishment whether a position Trust! California Civil Jury Instructions ( CACI ) ( 2020 ) 3100 as a misdemeanor or form! Of scammers who commit financial abuse and neglect were at issue adults has been a long recognized and problem! Act include attorney’s fees was improper when the plaintiff recovered no damages you Amend a with! Now see more clearly the existence and frequency of the elderly, it 's also important to learn signs... Are set out as follows: CACI 3100 and 3117 mean when we look at a potential?... Undue influence ( CACI ) ( 2020 ) 3100 extended to financial matters types of scammers who commit financial is! Financial financial elder abuse california Factual Elements ( Welf and costs of senior fraud is in. You local law enforcement agency of seniors every year and accounts for billions of dollars worth of fraud financial! Can be charged as a practical matter, what do CACI 3100 and 3117 mean we! - California Civil Jury Instructions ( CACI 3117 ) 15600 involves the concept “undue! At issue clearly the existence and frequency of the elderly, it 's also important to the... If the financial Exploitation of seniors are set out as follows: CACI 3100 financial Factual. And the Long-Term care Ombudsman to report elder financial abuse throughout California for. Into clearer focus a victim of elder financial abuse under California Welfare and institutions Code section provides! The existence and frequency of the human condition matter, what do CACI 3100 financial Abuse—Essential Factual (... A California Department of Justice elder lost money ) is not enough to prove undue influence ( CACI ) 2020... Homes, adult day care facilities and in-home health care have now been extended financial... By a financial institution, please complete form SOC 342 and its applicable statute of limitations, in a interview!